One of the most common complaints deniers made about my global warming skeptic challenge was "you cannot prove a negative" as an excuse for why they were unable to prove manmade global warming wasn't real. This, I told them, was a false statement. In fact, all experiments are designed to prove the negative. It's called the null hypothesis. The most common example I gave of proving the negative consisted of my saying the door is locked. If you were to try the door and find it is unlocked, you have proven the negative. I could come up with countless other examples (the Sun is in the backyard, cats are actually dogs, there is a gold coin under a given rock, deniers accept science, etc.), but that one works.
I was reminded of this when I saw an article from the National Science Foundation: Techniques to prove or disprove existence of other planets. Surely, that is just a title. They don't really mean they are proving a negative. Do they?
To the dismay of deniers everywhere - yes, they do mean that. The article is about how habitable planets had been identified around a particular star, Gliese 581, but new technology and methods proved the planets did not exist - "it was disappointing to disprove the habitable zone planets in the Gliese 581 system."
So, if you ever have someone say to you, "You can't prove a negative," be sure to tell them they are wrong and you can prove it. Isn't that actually proving a negative in itself?
Monday 9 March 2015
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Popular Posts
-
Climate Change: How Can Wind Energy Help? Wind energy plays an important role in addressing climate change on a global level. Many countrie...
-
[Updated May 7, 2015] Encyclicals. Pope Francis, the leader of the Roman Catholic Church, will soon issue a papal encyclical on global wa...
-
One of the false arguments deniers make is that polar ice is increasing, thus negating claims the world is getting warmer. Their line of rea...
-
Your roof (TGW) - Quiet Revolution, a London based small wind turbine maker, has raised $12.5 million in funding for its 6 kilowatt triple ...
-
Earth (TGW) - Online cartographers have taken a different look at how maps are made. Cartographers Danny Dorling and Anna Barford of the Uni...
-
Someone left a comment and asked me to take a look at an article appearing on the NoTricksZone website - Why There Is Global Warming . I ag...
-
Summary : California ’s Global Warming Solutions Act and Executive Order S-3-05 establish the goal of reducing emissions of greenhouse gas...
-
The world will have to reduce emissions more drastically than has been widely predicted, essentially ending the emission of carbon dioxide...
-
I began a new blog that will serve as a clearing house of articles on Tom Harris, ICSC and is affiliates. I will continue to add references ...
-
I recently came across an old email (sorry, it got lost in the bustle) from a reader who asked me to review the work of a particular climat...
0 comments:
Post a Comment